TSA$10.0B
Caribbean Business

When the Narrative Outruns the Truth: What the Theranos Documentary Teaches Corporate Leaders

Elizabeth Holmes’s return to the cameras humanizes a convicted founder, but for communicators the lesson is that empathy cannot replace specific, verifiable answers.

Opinion Column·By Vanessa Marzán··5 min read
a gloved hand holding a test tube filled with blood
Listen to this article
0:00 / 0:00

I walked out of the theater after watching “You Can See Everything,” the documentary featuring Elizabeth Holmes, founder of Theranos, with more questions than answers.

One question stood above the rest: Why would someone whose credibility has been so profoundly damaged agree to expose herself to the cameras once again?

The documentary offers an intimate look at Holmes, focusing heavily on her human dimension. Yet, from my perspective as a strategic communications consultant, what struck me most was not what she revealed, but what remained unanswered.

Throughout the film, I waited for specific explanations, verifiable information, and compelling evidence that might help audiences better understand her position.

Instead, many responses seemed ambiguous, leaving considerable room for interpretation.

Strategic communications cannot be reduced to making executives sound convincing. It must also ensure that organizational messages are accurate, defensible, and consistent with reality.

A documentary is not a courtroom. Nevertheless, when someone convicted of defrauding investors participates in such a public examination, credibility inevitably becomes part of the conversation. And credibility requires more than emotional connection.

Who Was Protecting the Corporate Narrative?

The Theranos scandal raises questions that extend beyond Holmes herself. The company promised a revolutionary approach to blood testing, attracting substantial investment, influential supporters, and extraordinary media attention.

It was a compelling story: an ambitious entrepreneur challenging conventional medicine through groundbreaking technology.

But who ensured that the story matched the science? Who prepared Holmes’ talking points? Who reviewed the claims communicated to investors? Who verified that statements about the technology were supported by scientific evidence? And what happened when the promises exceeded what the company could deliver?

We do not know every internal conversation or communications decision made at Theranos. Nor should we assume that every professional involved understood the full extent of the company’s problems.

Nevertheless, strategic communications cannot be reduced to making executives sound convincing. It must also ensure that organizational messages are accurate, defensible, and consistent with reality.

a gloved hand holding a test tube filled with liquid

When Persuasion Becomes a Liability

There is a critical distinction between communicating a vision and presenting an aspiration as an established fact. Entrepreneurs must inspire. Leaders must articulate possibilities. Organizations must communicate ambitions to attract talent, investment, and market confidence. But ambition is not evidence.

A compelling presentation cannot validate medical technology. A persuasive interview cannot replace scientific results. And an extraordinary corporate narrative cannot eliminate the responsibility to substantiate extraordinary claims.

This distinction becomes especially important in industries such as healthcare, biotechnology, and artificial intelligence, where technical complexity can make independent evaluation difficult.

The less equipped an audience is to verify a claim, the greater an organization’s responsibility to communicate it accurately.

The Missed Opportunity to Rebuild Credibility

Watching the documentary, I kept returning to another question: Was Holmes hoping to shift the pendulum of public opinion in her favor?

We cannot know her intentions simply from watching the film. Nor should we assume that the filmmakers intended to produce a reputation-rehabilitation campaign.

However, if influencing public perception was among Holmes’ objectives, I believe she missed a significant opportunity.

Humanizing someone can generate empathy. Showing vulnerability can make an individual more relatable. But empathy and credibility are not interchangeable.

woman in white dress shirt

Rebuilding trust after a serious reputational crisis requires specificity, transparency, accountability, and a willingness to confront uncomfortable facts.

From my perspective, Holmes had an opportunity to address difficult questions with greater clarity. Instead, I left with additional doubts. When credibility is already compromised, ambiguity rarely works in your favor.

What Corporate Leaders Should Learn

The Theranos case offers important lessons for CEOs, boards, entrepreneurs, and communications advisors. Communication must never move faster than organizational reality. Corporate messaging should reflect what products, services, and operations can actually deliver.

Communications professionals need the independence to question unsupported claims. Without that authority, strategic counsel becomes little more than message distribution. Reputation management also begins long before a crisis: it depends on accountability, ethical leadership, transparent decisions, and consistent behavior.

The less equipped an audience is to verify a claim, the greater an organization’s responsibility to communicate it accurately.

Finally, rebuilding credibility requires more than an effective media strategy. Audiences evaluate trust through evidence, actions, consistency, and responsibility. A sophisticated narrative may influence perception, but it cannot erase contradictions between promises and performance.

Truth Must Remain the Foundation

As communications professionals, we frequently discuss storytelling, executive presence, media training, and reputation management. All are valuable tools. None should be used to disguise organizational shortcomings or transform unverified claims into established truths.

Sometimes our greatest contribution is not helping executives find the right words, but having the courage to tell them that their message cannot be supported by the facts. That is when strategic communications becomes an essential component of corporate governance rather than merely a promotional function.

The Theranos story reminds us that powerful narratives can attract investors, dominate headlines, and create extraordinary expectations. But when the narrative outruns the truth, the consequences extend far beyond reputational damage.

Communication can amplify trust, but it can never substitute for truth. And credibility is not rebuilt by telling a more compelling story. It is rebuilt by demonstrating that the story deserves to be believed.

Vanessa Marzán Toro is a strategic communications consultant, executive communications advisor, author of “Habla menos, conecta más,” and president of Comm4Success Strategic Communications.

Related Articles