Big-box stores report a slight increase in sales, but smaller businesses taking a beating due to high electricity rates, inflation and other cost-increasing factors
Opening Editorial by CB Editor Philipe Schoene Roura
Killing Us Softly With AI Agents
Our lady of perpetual purchasing on the cover of this newspaper is meant to symbolize a new trend in consumerism under an umbrella called agentic commerce.
Yes, there is actually a thing called Agentic Buying that threatens to take all of the fun out of shopping. Imagine, no more “Marshalleando” — that hunt for the original Louis Vuitton handbag — at half the price. Instead, all you have to do is enter the prompts for size seven Jimmy Choos in leopard print and voilà, they are at your door the next day. The thrill of the hunt is gone.
The “there’s an AI agent for that” dynamic has upped the ante for malls, window dressers and other retail brigades hoping to capitalize on Puerto Rico’s never-ending Navidades by appealing to the robust consumer profile of our people. We believe Puerto Rico Retailers Association President Alan Taveras put it best when he told one of this journal’s reporters that: “there is always an upclip in retail sales during the holidays in Puerto Rico; nobody can tame boricua Christmas spirit. But the issue of profit margins remains complicated. We see consumers much more mindful of prices and looking for savings.”
That is a shared sentiment across the retail landscape from malls to boutique stores, a serious crimp on operating expenses that is preventing small and midsize businesses from rubbing two nickels together. Our team of reporters who put together this Holiday Retail Report found that there is “aggressive growth among large-format retail chains such as Burlington, Ross and Marshalls, which is redistributing market share within a market that is not growing rapidly.”
According to the latest retail sales report from the Department of Economic Development and Commerce (DDEC) for July 2026, small and midsize businesses recorded a combined 3.4% decline in sales. Small firms fell 3.0% and medium firms dropped 3.8%. In July alone, their share of sales slipped to 44.6%, compared to 45.6% a year earlier. These figures only measure sales dollars, rather than inflation-adjusted purchasing volumes or profitability.”
High electricity rates, inflation and inventory taxes have put a full nelson on profit margins. In fact, some economists interviewed by this journal say that if the cost of electricity remains at a national high of 33.86 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh), as many as 12,000 small and midsize businesses might shutter. That would not make for a very merry Octavitas.
So, let us rejoice in our never-ending Navidades by going to stores and shopping like it was a contact sport. As we say in Puerto Rico: La ultima que la pague el diablo.
— P.S.R., Editor
Main Story
As Puerto Rico’s retail industry heads into the final stretch of 2026 and the holiday season, a longstanding disconnect further intensifies. Namely, large retailers continue to grow and find more opportunties to expand, while smaller businesses struggle, perhaps harder than ever, to protect their shrinking sales and margins.
“There is aggressive growth among large-format retail chains such Burlington, Ross and Marshalls, which is redistributing market share within a market that is not growing rapidly,” said José González, president of the Puerto Rico Retailers Association (ACDET by its Spanish acronym).
According to the latest retail sales report from the Department of Economic Development and Commerce (DDEC) for July 2026, Puerto Rico retail sales from January through July totalled some $30.04 billion, roughly unchanged from the same period the previous year. Within that total, large-chain sales rose 2.8% and large non-chain businesses gained 5.3%.
Small and midsize businesses, meanwhile, recorded a combined 3.4% decline in sales. Small firms fell 3.0% and medium firms dropped 3.8%. In July alone, their share of sales slipped to 44.6%, compared to 45.6% a year earlier. Of note, these figures only measure sales dollars, rather than inflation-adjusted purchasing volumes or profitability.
“From the perspective of the DDEC numbers, they’re consistent with a market lacking strong growth, where new store openings affect the sales of other retailers,” said ACDET’s González.
The business logic behind the divide between big-box retailers and smaller stores remains fairly straightforward: Larger operators can spread purchasing, technology and administrative expenses across more sales and locations, with greater access to capital that can also help finance inventory. However, this dynamic has placed smaller stores in a tough predicament, having to often recover similar fixed expenses from a much narrower revenue base.
A Growing Divergence
The Puerto Rico Retailers Association (Centro Unido de Detallistas, or CUD), has made such an imbalance central to its agenda in recent months. Its “Fomento Local” plan for 2026–2028 proposes simpler access to incentives, changes to permitting, and sales-tax relief in traditional urban centers.
CUD President Alan Taveras Sepúlveda has argued that local businesses face an uneven environment when the incentives and administrative tools available to larger investors are harder for smaller firms to obtain.
Inflation has also placed more pressure on retailers, particularly when it comes to ever-changing consumer habits. A December 2025 study by research firm Nielsen, part of research comissioned by the Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce and based on 510 respondents, found that 79% of consumers had changed their spending habits, including reductions in entertainment, household services and monthly food budgets.
“Any economic projection depends critically on the duration and evolution of the war with Iran. The scenario is different if it ends soon versus if it drags on for months.”
Economist Vicente Feliciano, President of Advantage Business Consulting
During a February economic symposium held by the Financial Oversight and Management Board (FOMB), Leslie Adames, director of economic analysis and policy at San Juan-based research firm Estudios Técnicos, noted that inflation in essential goods, especially food, had remained far more intense than overall inflation suggested, with prices of some goods having doubled or tripled Puerto Rico’s average inflation rate.
Puerto Rico’s annual inflation rate stood at 3.8% in September 2026, according to estimates from the Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics. This is slightly higher than the U.S. inflation rate of 3.7%, according to September 2026 data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Meanwhile, the U.S./Israel war on Iran has led to higher gas prices since late February 2026, when the war began. As of late October 2026, Puerto Rico’s average gasoline price is about $1.29 per liter (approximately $4.88 per gallon), according to GlobalPetrolPrices.com. High gas prices often impact consumers’ pocketbooks, especially households with more than one vehicle. As with inflation, this can lead to changes in consumer behavior and a decrease in discretionary spending, affecting local businesses and the economy.
These factors, along with continuing high energy costs, have had an impact on the Island’s economic outlook for 2027, which widely points to an overall slowdown and perhaps even economic stagnation, and with some economists publicly questioning whether the Puerto Rico Government’s modest projects are still too optimistic. In September, the Puerto Rico Planning Board lowered its real gross national product (GNP) growth projections to 0.3% for fiscal 2026 and 0.2% for fiscal 2027. Estudios Técnicos’ Adames also warned in September that indicators pointed toward a slowing economy.
“From the perspective of the DDEC numbers, they’re consistent with a market lacking strong growth, where new store openings affect the sales of other retailers.”
José González, President, Puerto Rico Retailers Association
Energy Costs Intensify the Squeeze
Perhaps no other factor has placed more undue pressure on Puerto Rico’s retail segment, as well as consumers, than booming electricity costs. The Puerto Rico Energy Bureau’s (PREB) September 30 order approved a net increase of approximately 5.28 cents per kilowatt-hour in the combined fuel and purchased-power adjustments for October through December, leading to one of the highest rates in the nation.
In the regulator’s small-commercial example, monthly consumption of 1,200 kWh produces a bill of $435.24, up from $371.82, a 17.1% increase. Bills shown afterwards by various local business owners through local news and social media showed increases that were even higher and dwarfed the PREB’s example.
The CUD recently warned that 10,000 to 12,000 small and midsize businesses in Puerto Rico could close within three to six months if energy costs remained elevated, putting more than 70,000 jobs at risk.
Refrigeration makes the exposure particularly acute for supermarkets, neighborhood food stores and community pharmacies. CUD President Taveras Sepúlveda, among others, has warned that higher electricity and diesel costs also travel through the supply chain, affecting transportation and merchandise prices. The need for backup generators adds another expense, while lost operating time and spoiled inventory can compound the damage.
Inventory Tax Still an Issue
The inventory tax, part of the municipal personal-property tax administered by the Centro de Recaudación de Ingresos Municipales, or CRIM, remains a hot-button issue, with business groups saying it discourages companies from maintaining deep inventories and weakens the ability of smaller stores to compete.
Under Puerto Rico’s Municipal Code, merchandise held for sale is generally valued using the prior calendar year’s average inventory. This means the taxable base reflects goods held by the business, rather than its profits. Such a structure creates a recurring tension between having enough products on hand and limiting the expense of carrying them.
CUD’s Taveras Sepúlveda has criticized the stalled reform process and emphasized the contradiction of taxing stocks in an economy dependent on imported goods. For smaller merchants, the financial pressure can be particularly difficult: money allocated to inventory taxes is unavailable for additional merchandise, payroll or equipment. Larger chains also bear the tax burden, but purchasing scale and stronger financing can give them more room to manage it.
One significant change is already in force. Law 78-2025 exempted eligible prescription medicines from municipal personal-property taxation. This removes the inventory-tax burden on qualifying prescription drugs, benefiting community pharmacies and other eligible operators.
On the other hand, Gov. Jenniffer González Colón vetoed House Bill 420 in October 2025, despite bipartisan support. If signed, it would have frozen the tax for three years and provided for its elimination in 2028. Local business leaders widely condenmed the decision at the time.
In recent weeks, Gov. González announced she would seek authorization from the FOMB to exempt prepared food sold in restaurants from the Sales and Use Tax (SUT) during the months of November and December. The measure, which has the support of the Chamber of Commerce and the Restaurants Association (ASORE), would aim to mitigate the impact of the increase in electricity rates.
Electronic Commerce Hybridizes
As it turns out, the issue of the inventory tax dovetails with the prevalence of electronic shopping, particularly the growing trend of buying an item onine and picking it up at a local store.
“E-commerce does not ‘pay’ in the same way as traditional commerce, which raises questions regarding which taxes apply and who bears the responsibility,” said Vicente Feliciano, economist and president of Advantage Business Consulting. “There are new factors to consider concerning how inventory tax intersects with the growth of online shopping and its associated logistics.”
“Pick-up options are on the rise and it’s a service that clients are asking for,” said González. “Some chains and even some independent stores have capitalized on this trend better than others, dependiong on their operational execution.”
Not-so-secret Agents
It’s challenging enough for retailers who frequently strive to adjust and accomodate to customers’ ever-changing tastes and habits. But what happens when the shoppers are not even human?
It’s called “agentic shopping,”,or “agentic commerce” one of many offshoot technologies stemming from the current artificial intelligence (AI) boom. It’s also markedly different from the more common chatbots that frequently need human input.
In essence, a user would log on to any of the popular AI assistant platforms (also known as Large Language Models) out there, such as OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Anthropic’s Claude and Google’s Gemini. There are also dedicated platforms for this purpose available in the market.
With a sufficiently detailed prompt, the user could direct the platform to find them a quality dress or suit for less than $300 and deliverable by next Thursday, for example. An autonomous AI agent would take care of the rest of the process, comparing options among different products and vendors, putting items in the cart and even completing the checkout.
Granted, the above is an extreme example in terms of autonomy that is arguably in its beginning stages, at least in the customer space. Plenty of questions and concerns remain in the AI segment, especially concerning security. For instance, many customers are unlikely to trust an anutonomous AI program with their credit card information, but that hasn’t stopped vendors from continuing to push the technology.
While the end-user demand for agentic shoppers is unclear, particularly in the direct consumer space, expect a much wider early adoption in the business-to-business (B2B) arena, with agents being able to predict stock needs, negotiate prices with each other, coordinate transactions and manage overall procurement.
The Amazon Effect
There has arguably been no bigger story in Puerto Rico retail this year than the opening in August of the Island’s first Amazon warehouse, a $37 million, 100,000-square-foot last-mile delivery and distribution station in Dorado. Since then, Amazon vans have become ubiquitous, at least in the San Juan metro area.
“In terms of inventory tax, there is a clear, significant disadvantage compared to online retailers such as Amazon, and especially compared to platforms based outside the U.S., like Temu, given that local businesses in Puerto Rico are subject to an inventory tax,” said González.
Of note, there are no public details related to Amazon receving specific incentives or having a special deal with the Dorado municipality.
There is also the question of “inventory ownership” and who ultimately ends up with the tax responsibility. “If Amazon owns the inventory, it would, in theory, be liable for inventory tax. However, if the merchandise belongs to a third party— originating in Tennessee and arriving at an Amazon warehouse in Dorado—it has been argued that such goods would not be subject to inventory tax under this arrangement, as they do not constitute a purchase for resale,” explained Feliciano.
ACDET’s González echoed such remarks. “As a distribution center, the inventory would tend to remain for only a short time, keeping levels low and creating a competitive advantage.”
Commercial Vacancies Remain Low
Regarding commercial real estate, a slightly rosier picture emerges overall. A March 2026 retail report from JLL, a Chicago-based global commercial real-estate management company with offices in Puerto Rico, placed total vacancy at 5.7%, down from 6.5% a year earlier.
This has been mostly driven by aggressive expansion from brands such as Ross, Burlington and Planet Fitness, with international brands conducting feasibility studies for potential mid-to-late 2026 market entries.
Notable examples include the U.S. Postal Service securing 135,000 square feet (s.f.) of space at the former Kmart locale adjacent to Plaza Las Américas shopping center, in San Juan’s Hato Rey district; Ross adding 120,000 s.f. across six new locations, and Burlington opening 75,000 s.f. of new space throughout the Island.
Counterfeits a Growing Threat
Another growing trend has been that of stores selling counterfeit goods, most of them of Chinese manufacture.
“We are deeply concerned because we are seeing these stores selling counterfeit products, items that lack the necessary licenses or authorization to be sold within Puerto Rico or the United States. This is, first and foremost, a violation of both Puerto Rican and U.S. law. Furthermore, it constitutes unfair competition against legitimate businesses that comply with all the requirements for operating here,” emphasized González.
“It would not be a level playing field compared to businesses that purchase or license products officially, like for example, merchandise with Disney licenses/royalties versus imitations,” Feliciano agreed.
Uneven Road Ahead
If consumer demand remains subdued and operating costs stay high, as trends suggest, well-capitalized retailers will be better positioned to sustain promotions and absorb volatility. Some smaller merchants could respond through consolidations, shorter operating hours or narrower product selections. Specialized merchandise, dependable service and convenient local pickup can also give customers reasons to return.
The issue of business succession is also gaining more attention, with the CUD’s plan including the preservation of existing businesses and developing regional markets. That approach recognizes that economic development also involves keeping viable enterprises operating when owners retire and helping established firms reach additional customers.
As far as telling what the future holds, however, that is easier said that done, as many consumers and businesses continue to feel the squeeze. “Any economic projection depends critically on the duration and evolution of the war with Iran,” said Advantage Business Consulting’s Feliciano. “The scenario is different if it ends soon versus if it drags on for months.”
For public policy, the test will be whether permitting, financing and energy improvements become accessible to businesses with limited administrative capacity. More reliable and affordable electricity, along with easier access to the tools needed to compete, will help determine whether the next phase of retail growth reaches the neighborhood shopping street as well as the major commercial center.
The company that has continuously evolved to meet its clients’ needs is entering a new chapter, supported by international resources, technological innovation and opportunities for geographic expansion.