TSA$10.0B
Caribbean Business

Puerto Rico Permit Reform Delayed Until 2027 as Lawmakers Fail to Reach Consensus

Business groups were surprised by the move

Commerce·By Caribbean Business Staff··6 min read
Puerto Rico Permit Reform Delayed Until 2027 as Lawmakers Fail to Reach Consensus
Listen to this article
0:00 / 0:00

Puerto Rico’s long-awaited permit reform legislation will not be approved during the current legislative session after a conference committee failed to reconcile key differences between House and Senate versions of the measure before the close of legislative business on Tuesday, dealing a setback to what business groups have described as one of the island’s most important economic development initiatives.

According to legislative sources, the conference committee tasked with resolving differences between Senate Bill 1173, sponsored by Senate President Thomas Rivera Schatz, and Senate Bill 1183, submitted by Gov. Jenniffer González Colón, was unable to reach agreement on the final text of the comprehensive reform package. As a result, consideration of the legislation is expected to resume during the next regular legislative session, which begins in January 2027.

The legislation represents an extensive overhaul of Puerto Rico’s permitting framework and merges proposals advanced by both the Senate leadership and the governor’s administration. The Senate approved the substitute measure in October, while the House passed it on Nov. 12 with several amendments, setting the stage for conference negotiations between the two chambers.

At the center of the impasse were disagreements over the definition of the maritime-terrestrial zone, commonly known by its Spanish acronym ZMT, which differed substantially between the versions approved by the House and Senate. Sources also indicated that lawmakers were unable to resolve disagreements over several amendments proposed by the governor.

The conference committee, established Tuesday, faced the challenge of reconciling those differences within hours before the conclusion of the fourth ordinary legislative session. The measure spans approximately 867 pages and addresses a broad range of permitting, land-use and regulatory processes affecting businesses, developers and government agencies.

Earlier in the day, Rep. José “Pichy” Torres Zamora had warned that if lawmakers failed to reach an agreement before the session’s adjournment, the measure could be deferred until the next legislative session. Independent Sen. Johanne Vélez Veve likewise acknowledged that prospects for a deal appeared dim despite the significance of the proposal.

“There was nothing that occupied us more than the approval of this reform, which represents an important change for Puerto Rico’s economic development,” Vélez Veve said.

The delay drew mixed reactions from business organizations that have spent years advocating for changes to what many describe as an excessively complex and slow permitting process that discourages investment and increases development costs.

Alan Taveras, president of the United Retailers Center, told Teleonce that the decision was unexpected given assurances previously provided by legislative leaders.

“I had heard it might happen, but it still took us by surprise,” Taveras said. “The reality is that I had both legislative presidents here and they assured us this session the measure would be approved.”

While disappointment was evident among stakeholders eager to see the reform enacted, some business representatives argued that additional time could ultimately lead to a stronger and more workable framework.

Lisa García, executive director of the Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce, said lawmakers have attempted to undertake a thoughtful review of concerns raised by various sectors and suggested that waiting for broader agreement may be preferable to rushing through a measure whose regulations and implementation mechanisms are not yet fully developed.

“Although we want the process to move faster, we also want consensus on issues such as legal certainty, the maritime-terrestrial zone, community concerns and the ability of businesses to move forward,” García said. “If we have to wait until January to achieve greater consensus and approve it during the first quarter of the next legislative term, I think that is still progress.”

The comments reflect a growing recognition among business groups that some of the most contentious elements of the legislation involve politically sensitive questions surrounding environmental protections, coastal development and land-use policy, issues that have complicated efforts to enact a final compromise.

Sonia Navarro, president of ASOBRE, said the sheer breadth of the reform proposal has contributed to the legislative deadlock and argued that some less controversial sections could potentially move forward independently while lawmakers continue negotiating disputed provisions.

“One of the biggest issues has been how extensive this reform is and how much it covers,” Navarro said, noting that industry associations have begun discussing ways to separate certain operational improvements from the more divisive policy questions.

Navarro pointed specifically to longstanding inefficiencies involving coordination among municipalities, permitting offices, utilities and other agencies, which she said continue to hinder commercial activity across the island.

As an example, she described the experience of a Puerto Rican entrepreneur who returned to the island after two decades away and invested approximately $600,000 to open two restaurant locations. According to Navarro, one of those businesses spent four months waiting for a municipal permit, and both operations ultimately closed within roughly a year and a half.

“The interaction between LUMA, the Electric Power Authority, municipalities and the different agencies involved remains one of the greatest concerns,” Navarro told Teleonce. “There are things that can be streamlined while these other issues continue to be resolved.”

Business leaders also emphasized that lawmakers should use the intervening months not only to negotiate a legislative compromise but also to develop a clear implementation strategy for any eventual reform.

Taveras highlighted concerns surrounding the proposal’s transition from traditional use permits to a use-registration system, warning that policymakers must ensure businesses are not forced to incur additional costs or repeat bureaucratic processes during the changeover.

“We have to take advantage of this time not only to reach consensus but also to start thinking about implementation,” Taveras said. “Many businesses have already paid for their use permits. We need to consider how that transition will work. We cannot make small and medium-sized businesses pay again and become trapped in bureaucracy once more.”

He added that while policymakers have focused heavily on the legislation itself, successful implementation will ultimately determine whether the reform achieves its intended economic impact.

“This is going to radically change how business is done in Puerto Rico,” Taveras said. “Implementation is just as important as the public policy itself.”

For now, the setback means businesses, developers and investors will continue operating under the existing permitting framework while lawmakers attempt to resolve disagreements over coastal land definitions, protected rural lands and other provisions that have prevented final approval of one of the most consequential economic development measures considered by the current administration and Legislature.

Related Articles