TSA$10.0B
Caribbean Business

PREPA Bondholders, Oversight Board Clash Over Billions in Alleged Revenues in New Bankruptcy Court Filings

Matter to be discussed at omnibus hearing Nov. 18

Energy·By Eva Llorens··6 min read
PREPA Bondholders, Oversight Board Clash Over Billions in Alleged Revenues in New Bankruptcy Court Filings
Listen to this article
0:00 / 0:00

A new round of court filings in the long-running bankruptcy battle involving the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (PREPA) has laid bare a fundamental dispute that could shape the financial outcome of the utility’s debt restructuring: whether PREPA generated billions of dollars in revenues that should have been available to repay bondholders, or whether those funds were properly spent to maintain and rebuild Puerto Rico’s electric system.

The matter is slated to be discussed at an omnibus hearing Nov. 18.

The filings, submitted Nov. 16 in the Title III proceedings under PROMESA, pit PREPA bondholders against the Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico in a fight over how the utility’s “Net Revenues” should be calculated and whether bondholders are entitled to recover funds they claim were improperly diverted from debt service.

At the center of the litigation is Counterclaim IV, an accounting claim through which bondholders seek a determination of how much money remained after PREPA paid operating expenses during the bankruptcy period. The bondholders contend that PREPA generated billions of dollars in net revenues after the bankruptcy filing and that those funds should have been applied to bondholder claims under the utility’s 1974 Trust Agreement. The Oversight Board argues the opposite, maintaining that PREPA generated no net revenues at all during the Title III case and that essentially all available resources were required to operate, repair and rebuild the utility.

The dispute revolves around competing interpretations of the Trust Agreement that governs PREPA’s outstanding bonds. Bondholders argue the agreement, decades of bond disclosures and PREPA’s historical accounting practices establish a consistent methodology under which revenues are calculated on an accrual basis, municipal power consumption counts as revenue, and capital expenditures are not included among current operating expenses.

According to the bondholders, PREPA’s own monthly operating reports, or MORs, reflected that methodology for years and showed approximately $3.7 billion in net revenues between fiscal years 2018 and 2023. They argue the Oversight Board has created a new litigation-driven methodology that removes more than $1 billion in revenues and adds more than $1.5 billion in expenses to eliminate those net revenues.

“The Board cannot dispute the language of the Trust Agreement, the contents of PREPA’s offering statements and MORs, the testimony of PREPA’s corporate representative, or the record of PREPA’s post-petition spending,” bondholders wrote in a reply supporting their motion for summary judgment. They argue the utility generated “billions of dollars in Net Revenues that should have been used for debt service” and that the Oversight Board must account for and justify expenditures made from those funds.

The Oversight Board counters that the bondholders’ figures are based on preliminary monthly reports that were never intended to serve as definitive measures of net revenues. In its own motion for partial summary judgment, the Board argues the reports contain interim financial information subject to revision and do not calculate revenues and expenses in accordance with the Trust Agreement.

The Board further argues that PREPA’s financial condition and operational realities make the bondholders’ theory implausible.

“It is undisputed that PREPA has consistently ranked as the worst utility in the United States in a host of important metrics,” the Board wrote, describing a system weakened by decades of underinvestment, followed by hurricanes, earthquakes and other disasters that further damaged the grid.

According to the Oversight Board, the utility spent available resources on necessary operating expenses and grid improvements rather than accumulating surplus revenues for debt service. The Board argues federal disaster relief funds cannot be counted as revenues under the Trust Agreement and that major capital and infrastructure expenditures qualified as necessary operating expenses under federal bankruptcy law.

The competing expert analyses are evidence on how far apart the parties remain.

Bondholder expert Maureen Chakraborty calculated approximately $2.5 billion in net revenues for fiscal years 2018 through 2025, relying largely on PREPA’s historical reporting practices and accrual-based accounting. She testified that municipal electricity billings and related Contributions in Lieu of Taxes, or CILT, should be counted as revenues because PREPA historically treated them that way and because excluding them would alter the payment priority structure established in the Trust Agreement.

The Oversight Board’s expert, David Plastino, reached a sharply different conclusion. According to his analysis, corrections to the data used by Chakraborty reduce her revenue calculation by approximately $3.3 billion. Plastino ultimately concluded PREPA had roughly negative $1.1 billion in available net revenues during the relevant period. He argued that preliminary operating reports overstated available revenues, failed to account for additional LUMA-related expenses and omitted hundreds of millions of dollars in other expenses.

Among the most contentious issues is PREPA’s treatment of municipal electricity charges and the CILT program. Bondholders maintain that electricity consumed by municipalities produced revenues that should remain part of the net revenue calculation even when those amounts were offset against PREPA’s tax-related obligations to municipalities. The Oversight Board, however, argues those billings represent noncash and largely uncollectible amounts that should not be considered revenues available to service debt.

The parties also disagree over how federal disaster recovery funds should be treated. Bondholders contend federally funded or reimbursable projects should not diminish revenues pledged to bondholders and argue that if related expenses are deducted, corresponding federal reimbursements should be counted as revenues. The Oversight Board maintains that federal disaster-assistance funds are not revenues generated through operation of PREPA’s electric system and therefore cannot be included in the calculation.

Another key issue involves more than $1.5 billion in capital expenditures made during the bankruptcy period. Bondholders argue the Trust Agreement clearly distinguishes current operating expenses from capital improvements and places debt service ahead of capital spending in the payment hierarchy. The Oversight Board responds that PREPA’s deteriorated infrastructure left it with no choice but to undertake substantial investments to maintain service and that such spending qualifies as necessary operating expenses under Section 928(b) of the Bankruptcy Code.

The dispute has potentially significant consequences because bondholders are seeking not only an accounting but also disgorgement and restitution of funds they contend should have been preserved for debt service. The Oversight Board argues such remedies are unavailable, contending the First Circuit has already made clear that bondholders are limited to present and future net revenues rather than historical funds that have already been spent.

The filings represent one of the most consequential unresolved issues in PREPA’s bankruptcy. While previous appellate rulings clarified that bondholders possess a lien on PREPA’s present and future net revenues, the court has yet to determine how those revenues should be calculated and whether any recoverable amounts actually exist.

The bankruptcy court’s eventual decision on those questions could influence not only recoveries for PREPA bondholders but also the amount of financial flexibility available for Puerto Rico’s still-fragile electric system as it continues its long recovery from years of financial distress and repeated natural disasters.

Related Articles