TSA$10.0B
Caribbean Business

Squeezed but Still Celebrating, Local Shoppers Protect Spending on Children and Food, Study Finds

Arteaga & Arteaga’s Santa’s List finds 64% feel worse off than a year ago, yet 77% still plan to shop, and retailers that sell value, not just discounts, stand to win the season

Commerce·By Claudia Guerrero··6 min read
Blurry santa claus figures with festive lights
Listen to this article
0:00 / 0:00

As Puerto Rican consumers grapple with rising electricity costs, gasoline prices and grocery expenses, the financial strain is reshaping how they approach the holiday season.

While 64% report feeling financially worse off than a year ago, 77% still intend to shop for Christmas and Three Kings Day, according to a new study by advertising agency Arteaga & Arteaga.

The 13th edition of Santa’s List, which the agency has conducted since 2014 to track Puerto Rican consumers’ holiday preferences and purchasing behavior, set out to examine how retailers are adjusting their strategies as the island’s economy tightens household budgets.

“Consumers aren’t just spending less this Christmas. They’re deciding what’s worth investing in. The distance between what people want and what they can afford has widened in recent years,” said Juan Arteaga, founder of the agency, at a roundtable with the press.

The survey drew on 644 respondents across Puerto Rico between Oct. 16 and 30. It sought to learn not only what consumers plan to buy but also what they consider worth spending on.

Christmas tree with ornaments outside store window

Financial pressures reshaping household priorities

Of the 644 respondents, 64% said they felt worse or much worse financially than last year. In addition, 82% said the increase in electricity prices is affecting their household budgets, 74% said gasoline prices were a factor in their spending and 59% said the same about food price increases.

The responses mirror the data. The Labor Department’s consumer price index rose 3.8% in September from a year earlier, led by a 9.7% increase in transportation and a 33.2% jump in car fuel so far this year, as CB reported Nov. 2.

Residential electricity reached a record 33.86 cents per kilowatt-hour in October, as CB reported Oct. 27.

The presenters cautioned that the findings come after nearly a decade of overlapping crises, including hurricanes, earthquakes, the pandemic and ongoing energy challenges.

Arteaga said Puerto Rican consumers are resilient and will find ways to adjust financially, investing in necessities such as water cisterns, solar panels and emergency supplies to withstand whatever crisis comes next.

“We’ve spent nearly a decade navigating one crisis after another. Puerto Ricans are resilient, but that resilience has come at a cost, and today we’re seeing the consequences in household budgets,” he added.

That cost shows up in household finances. The Estudios Técnicos consumer financial fragility index rose to 42.2 in the second quarter from 33.7 in the first, and consumer-loan delinquency climbed to 3.07% from 2.62%, as CB reported in August and again Nov. 4.

Economist Heidi Calero told CB that middle-income families are being squeezed, “the ham in the sandwich.”

a close up of a window with a christmas tree in the background

Christmas remains an emotional priority

Despite economic hardship, the study found that 92% of those surveyed intend to celebrate Christmas in some form, while 75% view the season as an opportunity to disconnect from everyday routines or clear their minds.

The findings point to Christmas remaining a breathing space amid economic uncertainty on the island.

Among adults ages 18 to 34, 74% said connecting with loved ones gives Christmas its meaning, showing that the holiday’s significance still lies in keeping family traditions alive.

That meaning may protect certain expenses while others take a back seat. For retailers, understanding how those decisions are made is critical.

“Christmas becomes a moment of relief, even when finances are tight. People may not be able to celebrate the way they once did, but they still want to come together with their families,” said Aníbal Quiñones, creative vice president at the agency.

man in black jacket standing near building during night time

Cutting back, but not on everything

In drawing up their own Santa’s lists, consumers are deciding what is a priority and what is not, and decorations and some gifts are expenses that move down the list.

What remains essential are children’s gifts and food, which underscores the emotional connection to family at the heart of the holiday.

The study found that 55% of participants consider children’s gifts an untouchable expense, followed by Christmas dinner (41%), gifts for partners (33%) and gifts for parents (24%).

Among households with minors, 84% consider children’s gifts nonnegotiable. Another 44% intend to enjoy the season while staying mindful of spending limits, and 48% prefer to stay within their usual limits.

Presenters emphasized that consumers are cutting spending not so much by product category as by the person or occasion associated with a purchase.

“The budget is negotiable. The people behind it are not,” said Quiñones.

Food is the other protected expense, and it is also where price pressure is milder. Food and beverage prices rose 2.5% in the 12 months through September, against 3.8% for all items, according to the Labor Department figures CB reported Nov. 2, when Calero said families are “at the point where it is either food or electricity.”

Value over discounts

The main takeaway for retailers is that consumers are not necessarily looking for the best deal. Instead, they are being more cautious with their purchasing decisions, valuing emotional connection and services that address specific household needs.

For example, a better strategy for an appliance store might be to emphasize how an energy-efficient product can reduce a household’s electricity consumption rather than simply discounting it.

Similarly, food retailers could promote affordable solutions that make hosting family dinners easier, since only 23.7% of participants said they were willing to reduce expenses on food during this time.

“Businesses need to understand what matters to each consumer. It’s not just about offering a lower price, but about making their lives easier,” said Dr. José D. González of the agency’s Business Intelligence division.

The caution is visible elsewhere in retail. New-vehicle sales fell about 13% from January through September, according to figures cited by the Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce, as CB reported Nov. 5, and economists at the Oversight Board’s symposium pointed to weakening retail sales, as CB reported Nov. 4.

Blurred street lights and festive decorations at night

Understanding the decision process

Among those planning holiday purchases, the study found a sizable online segment, although physical stores still lead.

The study found that 54% of respondents intend to shop exclusively in physical stores, 22% intend to shop exclusively online and 24% expect to use both channels.

Among adults ages 18 to 34, 32% intend to shop exclusively online, while 61% of respondents ages 55 and older favor physical stores exclusively.

The researchers at the presentation stressed that businesses must understand the entire purchasing journey rather than focus exclusively on the final transaction.

“The purchase is an event, but the decision is a process,” they said. “By the time consumers reach the register, many of those decisions have already been made.”

Effective marketing requires businesses to reach consumers before they enter a store, through digital advertising, product information, promotions and other touchpoints.

While Puerto Rico’s economic challenges continue to influence household spending, the findings suggest that consumers are not abandoning the holiday season but redefining how they celebrate it.

For businesses, the challenge lies in understanding those changing priorities and delivering value beyond competitive pricing.

As the researchers emphasized, Christmas still matters to Puerto Rican families, but as the island’s economic climate shifts, so do consumers’ spending priorities and the factors that shape their purchasing decisions.

Related Articles