TSA$10.0B
Caribbean Business

October Jobs Data Show a Labor Market Running on Tourism While the Broader Economy Idles

Payrolls rose from a year earlier, but tourism supplied 80% of the gain, unemployment is above last year’s level, and large sectors shed jobs, a pattern that matches an economy ‘stuck in neutral’

Economy·By Alex Díaz··11 min read
a group of people standing next to each other
Listen to this article
0:00 / 0:00

Puerto Rico’s labor market grew modestly over the past year, but October’s numbers say less about a strengthening economy than about how narrow its sources of growth have become.

Nonfarm payroll employment reached 954,600 jobs in October, up 5,300 from October 2025, according to surveys released Friday by the Department of Labor and Human Resources (DTRH). Leisure and hospitality alone added 4,200 of those jobs.

The department’s household survey showed 1,185,000 people employed, up 23,000 from a year earlier, and a labor force participation rate of 45.4%, up 1.2 percentage points. The seasonally adjusted unemployment rate eased to 6.1% from 6.2% in September.

On a monthly basis, however, payrolls fell by 1,200 jobs from a revised 955,800 in September, led by a drop of 2,000 government jobs.

Labor Secretary María del Pilar Vélez Casanova said the annual comparison showed “favorable indicators,” particularly in payroll employment and the number of people working, and highlighted the rise in participation as a sign that more people are “joining or remaining in the labor force.”

She added that the results should be read “without losing sight of the fact that there are differences in the behavior of the various industries,” according to the department’s statement.

The startup sector is growing in the number of businesses, not yet in the number of large employers. That step from founder to significant hiring is where payroll growth outside tourism would have to come from.

Read alongside CB’s recent economy coverage, the October figures describe an economy that is adding workers to the labor force faster than it is creating jobs, leaning heavily on tourism and losing ground in government, professional services and construction, at a time when growth forecasts hover near zero and households face rising prices and power bills.

A gain carried by tourism

Six industries added jobs year over year: leisure and hospitality (4,200), trade, transportation and utilities (2,400), education and health services (1,500), manufacturing (1,300), financial activities (900) and other services (100). Four lost jobs: professional and business services (1,800), government (1,700), mining, logging and construction (800) and information (800).

Leisure and hospitality accounted for about 79% of the net annual gain. Excluding it, the rest of the payroll economy added roughly 1,100 jobs in a year, essentially flat for a base of more than 950,000 positions. The tourism gain is consistent with the visitor-economy data CB reported Nov. 3, when the Foundation for Puerto Rico projected about $7.9 billion in visitor spending for 2026, up 4.2%, and about 126,000 tourism-related jobs, with leisure and hospitality employment up 5% through September.

Payroll growth is also slowing. Total payroll employment grew about 0.6% year over year in October. As CB reported Nov. 4, September’s payrolls had been running about 0.8%, or roughly 7,600 jobs, ahead of a year earlier at the time of that report, and the September figure has since been revised down to 955,800 from 956,200.

Manufacturing’s 1,300-job gain is the most encouraging sign for the island’s longer-term base. As CB reported here, the Puerto Rico Manufacturers Association counted about $2.7 billion in investment commitments and about 2,800 jobs announced between September 2025 and September 2026, and Moody’s Analytics counted more than $2 billion in pharmaceutical and medical-device investment since 2025.

The October numbers suggest those Invest Puerto Rico announcements are beginning to reach payrolls, though slowly.

Blurred motion of people walking in a crowd

More people looking, not all are finding

The headline unemployment rate fell for the month, but the year-over-year picture is less favorable. The labor force grew by 31,000 people, to 1,263,000, while employment grew by 23,000.

By the department’s own figures, that puts the number of unemployed at about 77,000, up from about 70,000 a year earlier, when the implied unemployment rate was roughly 5.7%. As CB reported in September, the rate stood at 6.0% in July.

Rising participation is welcome on an island where it has long been among the lowest under the U.S. flag. Still, at 45.4%, Puerto Rico’s rate remains far below the national 61.9% reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics for October.

The CPA study CB reported Nov. 10 and Nov. 12 warned that a shrinking workforce is one of the island’s main constraints, with a scenario of about 213,000 fewer jobs by 2045 if current trends continue, and CB’s Nov. 17 report on the longevity economy noted that about 100,000 people aged 60 or older are now in the workforce, 17,000 more than in 2020, according to the Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics.

Readers should note that the two surveys measure different things. The payroll survey counts jobs at businesses and government agencies, while the household survey counts people, including the self-employed.

That explains why employment (1,185,000) is about 230,000 higher than payroll jobs (954,600). The participation rate is reported without seasonal adjustment, while most of the other household figures are seasonally adjusted, so its 0.3-point monthly drop to 45.4% from 45.7% does not line up neatly with the 3,000-person monthly rise in the labor force.

Workers the payroll survey does not see

The payroll survey counts jobs at employers, so founders and independent workers show up only in the household survey.

That is why household employment (1,185,000) is about 230,000 higher than payroll jobs, and most of that gap is people working for themselves.

In its September report, the most recent with a class-of-worker breakdown, the department counted 198,000 self-employed people, about 17% of those employed, in figures not adjusted for seasonality.

The department’s 2025 annual average was 208,000 self-employed workers, or 17.9% of employment, up 2.0% from 204,000 in 2024, and the Economic Development Bank estimated in 2022 that about two in 10 labor-force participants had created their own source of income, the highest level in 40 years, as CB reported Nov. 11.

But the September 2026 estimate was 15,000, or about 7%, below the 213,000 recorded a year earlier. A single month’s household estimate carries a margin of error, so the drop is more a signal than a trend, and the October breakdown was not part of today’s release.

The data also cannot say why people work on their own account. Some are entrepreneurs by choice, while others turn to independent work when payroll jobs are scarce, with unemployment at 6.1%.

Estudios Técnicos reported last year that 24.2% of employed people worked fewer than 34 hours a week in August 2025, up from 19.8% a year earlier, a sign that part of the island’s work is thinner than headline employment suggests.

Silhouettes of people walking with long shadows

Startup activity, meanwhile, is expanding by most measures. The state registered 27,439 new corporations in fiscal 2026, up 16.9%, as CB reported in that Nov. 11 story. Parallel18 counts more than 500 startups operating on the island, nearly 40% of them founded since 2020, with median revenue rising from $75,000 in 2022 to $500,000 in 2024, and Colmena66’s 2024 survey of 102 support organizations counted 22,100 jobs created and 10,100 businesses created, launched or scaled, as CB reported Sept. 3.

The Fase1 incubator has supported 232 startups since 2021, and its fifth cohort drew participants from 46 municipalities.

Yet little of that activity is visible in the payrolls. Payroll employment grew about 0.6% in the year, and professional and business services, which includes many consultancies and other services firms, lost 1,800 jobs.

Most new ventures begin as one- or two-person operations, and ManpowerGroup’s fourth-quarter survey found the strongest hiring intentions at firms with 10 to 49 workers (55%), against 17% for microbusinesses with fewer than 10, as CB reported Sept. 9.

The obstacles are familiar: in Colmena66’s 2025 survey of 555 entrepreneurs, a convenience sample, 44% named seed capital as an obstacle, 26% waited more than six months for permits and 63% cited inconsistent electricity.

The startup sector is growing in the number of businesses, not yet in the number of large employers. That step from founder to significant hiring is where payroll growth outside tourism would have to come from.

Where jobs are shrinking

Government, the island’s largest single employer, lost 1,700 jobs over the year and 2,000 in October alone, accounting for the entire monthly payroll decline and more.

The trend reflects fiscal pressure that will intensify. As CB reported Nov. 4, Medicaid funding is scheduled to fall from about $4.2 billion a year to about $500 million after Sept. 30, 2027, and the Oversight Board projects deficits above $1 billion a year from fiscal 2029.

The 1,800-job decline in professional and business services, a sector that includes the consulting, legal, accounting, engineering and administrative firms that serve other businesses, is a signal of softer corporate demand.

It fits the concerns business leaders raised in CB’s Nov. 5 report, when the Chamber of Commerce described the economy as anemic, with new-vehicle sales down about 13% from January through September and power costs mounting.

The 800-job loss in mining, logging and construction stands out given the reconstruction money still available. As CB reported Nov. 4, the Oversight Board counts about $56.2 billion in federal recovery funds still to be disbursed, and cement sales rose 2.2% in September from a year earlier.

That those funds have not yet translated into construction hiring is consistent with the permitting bottlenecks the governor’s reform, due for renewed legislative debate in January, aims to address.

Blurred figures create an abstract impression

How the jobs fit the broader economy

The labor figures line up with what economists told the Oversight Board this month. As CB reported Nov. 4, the Economic Development and Commerce Department’s Economic Activity Index stood at 129.4 points in September, up 0.8% from a year earlier, but down 0.2% over the first nine months of fiscal 2026.

V2A Consulting found that payroll employment had been largely unchanged since 2024. Moody’s Analytics projects real GDP growth of 0.3% in 2027, and Estudios Técnicos projects a 1.4% contraction in real GNP in fiscal 2027.

Jobs alone do not measure how households are faring. The DTRH’s own consumer price index rose 3.8% in September from a year earlier, with transportation costs up 9.7%, and residential electricity reached a record 33.86 cents per kilowatt-hour in October, as CB reported.

The Estudios Técnicos consumer financial fragility index rose to 42.2 in the second quarter from 33.7 in the first, and consumer-loan delinquencies climbed. The October release includes no wage data, so it cannot show whether paychecks are keeping pace.

In short, the labor market is not breaking down. Employment is at a high level, participation is rising, self-employment is growing, and unemployment is relatively stable. What it does not yet show is broad-based job creation outside tourism, the kind that would signal the economy is moving out of neutral.

a black and white photo of a person standing in front of a wall

What the labor market says about what comes next

Three trends will shape the next year. First, the growth sectors, as tourism continues its strong momentum, consolidating its place as the island’s new primary growth driver.

The former industry job-creation leader, manufacturing, is holding its own thanks to robust reshoring activity.

Both of those traditional industries are joined by the growth in less familiar and more diversified self-employment sectors.

Second, the education and health services sector, which added 1,500 jobs, depends heavily on federal Medicaid money that faces a cliff in September 2027.

Third, government payrolls are likely to keep shrinking as fiscal pressures mount.

Awaiting more signs of life are the reconstruction funds still to be spent and a workforce that is growing, in part because more older residents are staying on the job.

Whether hiring grows will depend on decisions outside the labor market: how quickly permitting reform moves projects, whether Congress addresses Medicaid funding, and how energy costs evolve for employers, particularly in the face of a possible Pymes Power Cliff.

The October report, then, is less a verdict than a warning light. The economy is producing jobs, but mostly in one sector, while more people enter the labor force looking for work that the rest of the economy is not yet creating.

Until manufacturing, construction and professional services begin to hire at the pace of hotels and restaurants, the jobs numbers will continue to describe an economy holding steady rather than one gaining momentum.

Related Articles